1801 S La Cienega Blvd #1, Los Angeles, CA 90035

lalocksmith24@gmail.com

1801 S La Cienega Blvd #1, Los Angeles, CA 90035

Key Duplication vs Rekeying: Which Saves More Money?

Key Duplication

If you have ever misplaced a key, hired a new employee, or moved into a new building, you have probably faced a simple but important question. Should you duplicate your existing keys or should you rekey the lock entirely? Both options solve access problems, but they work in different ways and come with different costs. Understanding the difference can help property owners, tenants, and business managers make a decision that protects their budget and their security at the same time.

At LA Best Locksmith, this is one of the most common questions asked by both residential and commercial clients. Whether you need a simple building key copying service or a full lock rekey after a security concern, knowing the cost and purpose of each option makes the process much easier. You can learn more about the team behind these services on the about us page.

In this article, we will break down what key duplication and rekeying actually involve, compare their costs, and help you decide which option fits your situation best.

What Is Key Duplication

Key duplication, sometimes called key copying, is the process of creating an exact copy of an existing key. A locksmith or key cutting machine reads the pattern of the original key and cuts a blank key to match. The new key works exactly the same way as the original because it fits the same lock mechanism.

This is one of the most affordable and quick locksmith services available. Property managers often need building key duplication when they have multiple tenants, staff members, or family members who need access to the same space. It does not change the lock itself, only adds more working keys to the existing system.

When Key Duplication Makes Sense

Key duplication is a practical choice in several everyday situations, including:

  • Giving a spare key to a family member or roommate
  • Providing office staff with access to a shared entrance
  • Replacing a worn out key that still works but is becoming difficult to use
  • Supplying keys for a new employee at a business location
  • Keeping a backup key stored safely in case of future lockouts

 

A reliable building key copying service can usually complete this task in a matter of minutes, which is one of the reasons it remains a popular and cost effective solution for most access needs.

What Is Rekeying

Rekeying is a different process altogether. Instead of copying a key, a locksmith changes the internal pins or wafers inside the lock cylinder so that the old key no longer works. A new key is cut to match the updated pin configuration, and only that new key will open the lock going forward.

Rekeying is commonly used when security is the main concern rather than convenience. For example, if a former employee still has a key to the office, simply duplicating more keys will not solve the problem. The lock needs to be rekeyed so the old key becomes useless.

When Rekeying Makes Sense

Rekeying is the better option in situations such as:

  • Moving into a new home or office where previous occupants may still have keys
  • Losing a key or having one stolen
  • Ending employment with someone who had building access
  • Recovering from a break in or attempted break in
  • Wanting tighter control over who can enter a property

 

Unlike duplication, rekeying directly changes the security of the lock, which makes it a more involved and slightly more expensive service.

Key Duplication vs Rekeying: Cost Comparison

The cost difference between these two services is one of the biggest factors people consider before making a decision. Below is a general comparison to help illustrate how the two options differ in price, time, and purpose.

FactorKey DuplicationRekeying
Average cost per key or lockLow, usually a few dollars per keyModerate, depends on number of locks
Time requiredA few minutesFifteen to thirty minutes per lock
Changes lock securityNoYes
Best forAdding more accessRemoving old access
Common use caseNew tenant, spare key, extra staff keyLost key, move in, security concern
Number of locks affectedNone, only the key is copiedEach lock being rekeyed

As the table shows, duplication is almost always the cheaper option because it does not involve any changes to the lock mechanism. Rekeying costs more because it requires labor to disassemble the lock, replace the pins, and test the new key, but it delivers a real security upgrade that duplication cannot provide.

Which Option Actually Saves More Money

The honest answer depends on what problem you are trying to solve. If your only goal is to have more working keys for people you trust, duplication is clearly the more economical choice. There is no reason to pay for a full rekey when a simple copy will do the job.

However, if security is a concern, choosing duplication just because it is cheaper can end up costing more in the long run. A property that continues to use the same lock after a key is lost or after someone with bad intentions had access is at ongoing risk. A break in, theft, or liability issue resulting from an unresolved security gap will almost always cost far more than the price of a rekey.

For commercial properties in particular, this decision matters even more. Commercial key copying is often needed for daily operational reasons, such as onboarding new staff or providing access to different departments. But when an employee leaves the company, especially under difficult circumstances, rekeying becomes the responsible choice rather than simply managing more copies of the same key.

In short, duplication saves money on convenience related needs, while rekeying saves money on security related risks by preventing costly incidents before they happen.

How to Decide Between the Two

A simple way to approach this decision is to ask one question. Does this situation involve adding trusted access, or does it involve removing access that should no longer exist?

If you are adding access for someone you trust, such as a new roommate, employee, or family member, duplicating your key is usually enough. If you are dealing with a lost key, a change in occupancy, or any situation where someone who should not have access might still hold a key, rekeying is the safer and more responsible choice.

Many property owners choose to combine both services over time. They may use a building key copy service for everyday access needs while scheduling a rekey whenever there is a change in tenants, staff, or ownership. This balanced approach keeps costs manageable while still protecting the property when it matters most.

Duplicate Building Keys the Right Way

When it comes to commercial or residential buildings with multiple access points, it is important to work with a professional rather than relying on automated kiosks found in retail stores. Buildings often use restricted or high security key systems that cannot be duplicated without proper authorization and equipment. Attempting to duplicate these keys through unauthorized means can result in poorly cut keys that damage the lock or fail to work altogether.

A professional locksmith can accurately duplicate building keys using the correct blanks and cutting equipment, ensuring the new key functions smoothly from the very first use. This is especially important for master key systems, where a poorly cut duplicate can interfere with the entire building access hierarchy.

For vehicle owners who also need key services, it is worth noting that key duplication and rekeying principles apply differently to cars. If you need assistance with car keys or fobs, an automotive locksmith can help with those specific requirements separately from building locks.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between key duplication and rekeying does not have to be complicated once you understand what each service actually does. Duplication is fast, affordable, and ideal for adding more working keys to a system that is already secure. Rekeying is a bit more involved and costs more, but it is the right choice whenever security needs to be restored or tightened.

Rather than choosing based on price alone, it helps to think about the purpose behind the request. Saving a few dollars on duplication when a rekey is truly needed can lead to much larger expenses later if the property is left vulnerable. On the other hand, paying for a rekey when a simple copy would have worked just adds unnecessary cost.

If you are unsure which service fits your situation, a licensed locksmith can assess your locks and recommend the most practical and cost effective solution. To discuss your specific needs or to schedule a service, you can contact us and speak with a team member who can guide you through the right option for your property.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is key duplication cheaper than rekeying?

Yes, in most cases key duplication costs significantly less than rekeying because it only involves cutting a new key rather than modifying the internal parts of the lock.

2. Can any locksmith duplicate a building key?

Not always. Many buildings use restricted key systems that require proper authorization and specialized equipment, so it is best to work with a professional who understands these systems.

3. How long does rekeying a lock usually take?

Rekeying typically takes between fifteen and thirty minutes per lock, depending on the type of lock and how many locks need to be changed.

4. Do I need to rekey after losing a key?

It is generally recommended, especially if the lost key could grant access to your home or business. Rekeying ensures the missing key can no longer be used to enter the property.

Chat with us